HemGrupperDiskuteraMerTidsandan
Sök igenom hela webbplatsen
Denna webbplats använder kakor för att fungera optimalt, analysera användarbeteende och för att visa reklam (om du inte är inloggad). Genom att använda LibraryThing intygar du att du har läst och förstått våra Regler och integritetspolicy. All användning av denna webbplats lyder under dessa regler.

Resultat från Google Book Search

Klicka på en bild för att gå till Google Book Search.

Mary, Queen of Scots av Jenny Wormald
Laddar...

Mary, Queen of Scots (urspr publ 1988; utgåvan 2018)

av Jenny Wormald (Författare), Anna Groundwater (Förord)

MedlemmarRecensionerPopularitetGenomsnittligt betygOmnämnanden
1092248,282 (3.32)2
Mary Stuart, Queen of Scots, has long been portrayed as one of history's romantically tragic figures. Devious, naive, beautiful and sexually voracious, often highly principled, she secured the Scottish throne and bolstered the position of the Catholic Church in Scotland. Her plotting, including probable involvement in the murder of her husband Lord Darnley, led to her flight from Scotland and imprisonment by her equally ambitious cousin and fellow queen, Elizabeth of England. Yet when Elizabeth ordered Mary's execution in 1587 it was an act of exasperated frustration rather than political wrath. Unlike biographies of Mary predating this work, this masterly study set out to show Mary as she really was - not a romantic heroine, but the ruler of a European kingdom with far greater economic and political importance than its size or location would indicate. Wormald also showed that Mary's downfall was not simply because of the 'crisis years' of 1565-7, but because of her way of dealing, or failing to deal, with the problems facing her as a renaissance monarch. She was tragic because she was born to supreme power but was wholly incapable of coping with its responsibilities. Her extraordinary story has become one of the most colourful and emotionally searing tales of western history, and it is here fully reconsidered by a leading specialist of the period. Jenny Wormald's beautifully written biography will appeal to students and general readers alike.… (mer)
Medlem:SassyLassy
Titel:Mary, Queen of Scots
Författare:Jenny Wormald (Författare)
Andra författare:Anna Groundwater (Förord)
Info:Edinburgh: Birlinn
Samlingar:Ditt bibliotek
Betyg:
Taggar:Scotland, History, Biography

Verksinformation

Mary Queen of Scots: a study in failure av Jenny Wormald (1988)

Ingen/inga
Laddar...

Gå med i LibraryThing för att få reda på om du skulle tycka om den här boken.

Det finns inga diskussioner på LibraryThing om den här boken.

» Se även 2 omnämnanden

Visar 2 av 2
The dangerous tendency of biographers is to become too fond of their subjects. No worries about that happening here! The way Jenny Wormald goes after Mary Queen of Scots, you'd think Mary was Richard III and Wormald was William Shakespeare trying to make propaganda look real.

This book, when it came out, was intended as something of a corrective to a view of history that made Mary Stewart mostly an innocent victim of circumstance. But Wormald's answer -- that Mary never took any actions, even when action was required, except that she worked actively to make the religious situation worse -- is no better answer.

Making it worse is Wormald's rhetorical style -- the constant disdain for her subject. She considers Mary lazy and stupid, and never allows for the complex situation the Queen found herself in. There is the sneering air of "of course she knew what was happening" -- e.g. Mary of course must have known that there was a conspiracy to murder Lord Darnley, even though Wormald offers no actual evidence. Nor does Wormald give Mary any credit for not trying to stoke the religious wars. Wormald gives the impression that Scotland was meant to be Protestant, and Mary should have just gotten aboard and helped it along. This is quite absurd -- while Mary's half-brother James Earl of Moray, one of the supports of her government but also one of the main leaders of the revolt against her, was Protestant, as was her third husband the Earl of Bothwell, and an illegal parliament of 1560 had officially made the nation Protestant and barred Catholic worship, there were still many Catholics (including quite a few earls and barons) in Scotland as well. Mary mostly offered toleration -- not considered a virtue at the time, but it at least offered Scotland a chance to work out its own troubles.

It is certainly true that Mary made bad decisions -- mostly when she let her emotions get away with her, as when she married Lord Darnley, then (when he was dead), she married Earl Bothwell, then finally when she fled to England rather than continue to fight on her own behalf. The first produced an insoluble crisis (there was a reason Darnley was murdered; he was simply impossible), the second cost her her throne, the last cost her her freedom and her life. The way I would put it is that Mary was dealt a poor hand which she played very badly. She was clearly emotionally disordered somehow, and she often let her emotions do her thinking for her, and she lived at a time when any mistakes she made were almost sure to prove costly.

And yet, people liked her; she was clearly very charming (although the claim that she was beautiful seems to be disproved by her portraits). She had genuine skills, if not the skills we really expect of a monarch. She did, in fact, like to work, as well as to go out and ride and hunt and exercise. She had a devoted following, if not a very effective following. In the right context, she might have done reasonably well as a Queen.

A good biography of Mary should certainly show the dark side of her reign -- the strife, the lack of governance, the instability that cost Mary her throne, as well as Mary's own inability to work out the best course of action. But by making Mary such a passive failure, Wormald makes it impossible to truly understand what happened. If all of Mary's decisions are stupid and harmful, how can one tell which ones were disastrous and which ones were not particularly important? Ultimately, this is a hatchet job, and it feels like it, and it damages its own case by being one. ( )
  waltzmn | Mar 16, 2024 |
The subtitle of this book, A Study in Failure, drew me to it as I'd always thought that Mary Queen of Scots wasn't really cut out to be a monarch especially at that very difficult time in European history when great religious ferment was in progress due to the establishment of the Protestant religion. However, I found it a bit disappointing. It isn't a personal biography and I didn't expect that - and the author recommends Antonia Fraser's study which I read years ago - but somehow it seemed a bit superficial.

There were a few interesting points such as the layout of the palaces at that time allowing a monarch to withdraw and cut themselves off with their 'favourites', and the statistics on how few council meetings Mary did attend. It was also interesting that she was depicted in the Casket Letters, which implicated her in the murder of her second husband, as a lovelorn masochist which the author says would have been novel if these had been forged by one of the men who stood to gain from her being deposed - as women at the time were either categorised as Madonna/Whore. Probably correct, as the concept of sadomasochism was not, I believe, developed until the 18th century. Though rather than likening this to Barbara Cartland novels as the author does, I would have thought 1980s bodicerippers would have been more accurate a comparison - and contemporary to the original publication of this book. A 3-star read, with some interest but not as enjoyable or informative as I'd hoped. ( )
  kitsune_reader | Nov 23, 2023 |
Visar 2 av 2
inga recensioner | lägg till en recension

» Lägg till fler författare (1 möjlig)

Författarens namnRollTyp av författareVerk?Status
Jenny Wormaldprimär författarealla utgåvorberäknat
Groundwater, AnnaFörordmedförfattarevissa utgåvorbekräftat
Witz, CorneliaÖversättaremedförfattarevissa utgåvorbekräftat
Du måste logga in för att ändra Allmänna fakta.
Mer hjälp finns på hjälpsidan för Allmänna fakta.
Vedertagen titel
Information från den engelska sidan med allmänna fakta. Redigera om du vill anpassa till ditt språk.
Originaltitel
Alternativa titlar
Information från den engelska sidan med allmänna fakta. Redigera om du vill anpassa till ditt språk.
Första utgivningsdatum
Personer/gestalter
Information från den engelska sidan med allmänna fakta. Redigera om du vill anpassa till ditt språk.
Viktiga platser
Information från den engelska sidan med allmänna fakta. Redigera om du vill anpassa till ditt språk.
Viktiga händelser
Relaterade filmer
Motto
Dedikation
Inledande ord
Information från den engelska sidan med allmänna fakta. Redigera om du vill anpassa till ditt språk.
Mary Queen of Scots was born in the palace of Linlithgow on 7 or 8 December 1542.
Citat
Avslutande ord
Särskiljningsnotis
Förlagets redaktörer
På omslaget citeras
Ursprungsspråk
Information från den engelska sidan med allmänna fakta. Redigera om du vill anpassa till ditt språk.
Kanonisk DDC/MDS
Kanonisk LCC

Hänvisningar till detta verk hos externa resurser.

Wikipedia på engelska (1)

Mary Stuart, Queen of Scots, has long been portrayed as one of history's romantically tragic figures. Devious, naive, beautiful and sexually voracious, often highly principled, she secured the Scottish throne and bolstered the position of the Catholic Church in Scotland. Her plotting, including probable involvement in the murder of her husband Lord Darnley, led to her flight from Scotland and imprisonment by her equally ambitious cousin and fellow queen, Elizabeth of England. Yet when Elizabeth ordered Mary's execution in 1587 it was an act of exasperated frustration rather than political wrath. Unlike biographies of Mary predating this work, this masterly study set out to show Mary as she really was - not a romantic heroine, but the ruler of a European kingdom with far greater economic and political importance than its size or location would indicate. Wormald also showed that Mary's downfall was not simply because of the 'crisis years' of 1565-7, but because of her way of dealing, or failing to deal, with the problems facing her as a renaissance monarch. She was tragic because she was born to supreme power but was wholly incapable of coping with its responsibilities. Her extraordinary story has become one of the most colourful and emotionally searing tales of western history, and it is here fully reconsidered by a leading specialist of the period. Jenny Wormald's beautifully written biography will appeal to students and general readers alike.

Inga biblioteksbeskrivningar kunde hittas.

Bokbeskrivning
Haiku-sammanfattning

Pågående diskussioner

Ingen/inga

Populära omslag

Snabblänkar

Betyg

Medelbetyg: (3.32)
0.5
1
1.5 1
2
2.5 3
3 3
3.5 3
4 2
4.5
5 2

Är det här du?

Bli LibraryThing-författare.

 

Om | Kontakt | LibraryThing.com | Sekretess/Villkor | Hjälp/Vanliga frågor | Blogg | Butik | APIs | TinyCat | Efterlämnade bibliotek | Förhandsrecensenter | Allmänna fakta | 203,242,217 böcker! | Topplisten: Alltid synlig