I've seen Jones described as "aggressively mediocre" but I really liked this. The characters were just complex enough to be engaging. As was the plot.I had a bit of a problem with C. marrying Angeline. What's-his-name's desctiption of her as his "mindless child-wife" was a bit too accurate. I mean, she amused herself by counting her dog's toes! And Tessa and Ravis's romance developed a bit too quickly. ( )

I felt that this book had a couple of novel and interesting fantasy ideas, written in a readable style, but embedded in a fairly cliché plot structure with fairly stereotypical characters. In short, this came across as just OK.

The device of a person from our world being transported to the fantasy world is getting old. When this transportation is an essential element woven through the plot, it can work well. When it's done so that the author can explain the world out loud to the reader, it's disappointing. That was the case here; Tessa's "our world" origin serves absolutely no purpose in the story and is quickly forgotten. In fact, she suffers almost no culture shock in her transition from the 20th century to something like the 17th.

The character roles were annoyingly "stock". Retiring, handicapped Tessa becomes the beautiful and powerful heroine. Ravis is the dashing man with a mysterious past, the consummate fighter, who starts off as the bad guy but secretly has a warm heart and is really the good guy. The prince-who-didn't-know-he-was-a-prince must fight for his throne. The bad guys are unrelentingly evil. In the end, everyone pairs up and lives happily ever after…except the bad guys who are all dead. They are no gray characters in this novel.

On the positive side, the whole concept behind the story was fairly interesting. I would have loved more depth to her ideas of Ephemera and Illumination, for they showed originality. And Ms. Jones writes well—though the characters may have been a little flat in depth of character, they were well-drawn and the writing flowed easily along.

I don't rule out the possibility of ever reading another Jones novel, but she's certainly not an author I'm hungering to read again. ( )

While at first, I thought that her writing was a little overdramatic (quite a lot of rain-tossed stormy nights, etc.) it definitely grows on you. Her characters are all well portrayed, being neither so good you want to retch, nor so bad you yawn when they show up on screen. While the mood of the book is rather heavy, there are a few instances of humor to lighten it up. Not as many as I'd have liked...but still. I'd have preferred it if she'd have set the time-line up a bit more explicitly, and defined the geographical placement of certain landmarks, but those're just details. By the middle of the book, I didn't want to put it down - sleep, activity, were just random irritating interruptions. (Growl at stupid body. You don't need sleep! Pull yerself together man!) There was a fair amount of action - sometimes the times when the characters went off into bouts of self-musing were disrupting (and like I said, a bit overly dramatic) but she soon pulled them out of it and sent them back into the fray. But it did make me cry, over something that usually wouldn't have. (Yeah, I'm a sucker.) Overall, a very good book. 8.5/10

J.V. Jones Rocks!!! This was the first novel I read by her. I loved it becasue it doesn't have that polished feel that so many fantasy novels possess. Gritty, well-written and a good story! ( )