Bild på författaren.
22 verk 461 medlemmar 10 recensioner

Om författaren

Tim Bowden is an acclaimed oral historian, broadcaster, and radio and television documentary maker for the ABC. He is author of many books including the much acclaimed One Crowded Hour: Neil Davis, combat cameraman, The Changi Camera: A unique record of Changi and the Thai-Burma Railway, and visa mer Stubborn Buggers: Survivors of the infamous POW gaol that made Changi look like heaven. visa färre

Inkluderar namnet: Tim Bowden

Foto taget av: Courtesy of Allen and Unwin

Verk av Tim Bowden

Taggad

Allmänna fakta

Medlemmar

Recensioner

I read this in 1997 and had some doubts about how and why Bowden included some content, and I've just revisited it and still feel the same, if not more so.
To see my review please visit anzlitlovers.com
 
Flaggad
anzlitlovers | 5 andra recensioner | Feb 11, 2023 |
I read up to page 40, not much liking the tone of the book or its racism and vulgarity, but remaining mindful that these young men being valorised by Tim Bowden had put their lives on the line for the liberation of Europe and Southeast Asia.

However, when I read the racist remark quoted on page 40, that was it. I just didn’t want to read any more of it. I can’t bear the thought of any Indigenous Australian coming across this in print in the 21st century either.

I think the publication of this book is a mistake. Some readers may find it amusing, but quite apart from needing some professional development about contemporary attitudes to racism, the A&U editorial team and Tim Bowden should read what James Brown says in his book Anzac’s Long Shadow (Black Inc 2014)
…by fostering the myth of the Aussie digger (braver and smarter than all other soldiers anywhere, lack of training notwithstanding) we are deluding ourselves if we imagine that similar unpreparedness can be victorious in future wars in our vicinity. And we’re not doing ourselves any favours by perpetrating the pseudo-democratic notion of contempt for the officers who lead them.
In a 2010 memorial lecture for Sir John Hackett, the current chief of the ADF, General David Hurley, outlined the kind of skills needed to operate in a ‘volatile, uncertain, complex and ambiguous’ region. In his view, Australia would face particular challenges in defending itself in this turbulent new world, lacking advantages in military size and unable to maintain a broad technological edge over regional powers. Australia’s military leaders would need to operate remotely and autonomously, and possess a deep understanding of the cultures, languages* and ways of thinking of regional countries. In short, Hurley suggested, defence would need to adopt a highly innovative culture and mould a new kind of officer – one able to master innovative strategy, strive for intellectual excellence, develop deep knowledge as well as strategically important personal relationships in two regional societies, and most importantly, think critically and analytically. (p. 105, bold highlight mine.)


IMO the unpublished and self-published memoirs of these men were not published for very good reasons, and A&U would have been better to have left it that way.
… (mer)
 
Flaggad
anzlitlovers | Jul 26, 2019 |
One of my favourite books on a war correspondence/ photojournalist.
This is a well written biography of a courageous and large as life Australian who took immense risks to photograph the atrocities of war. For over twenty years journalist Neil Davis covered the conflicts in SouthEast Asia. Always at the battle front, he brought enduring images of the full horror of modern war to the world. Ironically, in September 1985, having survived so much war, Neil Davis was killed filming an attempted coup in the streets of Bangkok.… (mer)
 
Flaggad
lulu8 | 5 andra recensioner | May 13, 2008 |

Du skulle kanske också gilla

Statistik

Verk
22
Medlemmar
461
Popularitet
#53,308
Betyg
4.2
Recensioner
10
ISBN
108

Tabeller & diagram