Bild på författaren.

Jane Ellen Harrison (1850–1928)

Författare till Prolegomena to the Study of Greek Religion

24+ verk 647 medlemmar 8 recensioner 2 favoritmärkta

Om författaren

One of the first women to study classics at Cambridge University, Jane Harrison enjoyed a global reputation based on her writings about Greek religion. At a time when the study of texts was often seen as the only means to study ancient religions, Harrison helped break new ground by using materials visa mer and insights derived from archaeology, art history, and comparative anthropology. In Harrison's view, religion is primarily something done; words and reflection come later. In writing on Greek religion, she made a sharp distinction between the cult of the Olympian deities, which she initially devalued, and non-Olympian practices. She correlated this distinction with one between rituals of tendence and rituals of aversion, that is, rituals that venerate and those that seek to ward off potentially evil spirits. In accordance with views popular at the time, she also gave her classification an evolutionary twist, attributing the Olympian cult to invading Indo-European patriarchs from the north, and the non-Olympian practices to a matriarchal, pre-Indo-European, Mediterranean civilization. Readers should approach Harrison's entirely speculative, historical reconstruction with extreme caution. As is true for virtually every scholar of Harrison's generation, the value of her writing consists in the potential elucidation that her questions and categories can provide, not in the results of her actual investigations. Together with James G. Frazer and the so-called Cambridge Ritualists, Harrison has recently been the object of intense biographical scrutiny. (Bowker Author Biography) visa färre
Foto taget av: Jane Ellen Harrison

Verk av Jane Ellen Harrison

Associerade verk

Osiris and the Egyptian resurrection (1911) — Inledning, vissa utgåvor99 exemplar
Prosten Avvakums levnadsbeskrivning av honom själv nedtecknad (1924) — Översättare, vissa utgåvor61 exemplar

Taggad

Allmänna fakta

Medlemmar

Recensioner

Interesting if brief look at the history of ancient Greek religion. This book was originally published in the early 20th century, and while it's archeological and linguistic data hasn't aged particularly well, it's overall coverage and discussion is excellent.
 
Flaggad
dhaxton | 1 annan recension | Sep 15, 2023 |
Translations of Russian tales, some traditional, others by Remizov, Krylov, Garshin, Pushkin, Chemitzer, Tolstoy. A very mixed bag - some are charming, some are simply obscure. Ray Garnett's illustrations are beautifully done and compliment the text well. The printing (on art vellum) and binding are very nice examples of fine British press work of the period. All in all, a lovely little book that is worthy of The Nonesuch Press.
 
Flaggad
John_Thorne | Sep 12, 2017 |
"The Lithuanians in the Middle Ages are said to have made their beer over-night and drunk it next morning. Beer of this primitive kind was best sucked up through a pipe."
I bet!
"the characteristic essence of the worship of Dionysos...was intoxication...a divine madness." cf William James discussion of similar ideas in his Varieties of Religious Experience.
I skim read large sections but this one on intoxication in Harrison's book, along with most of the sections on Orpheus and Aristophanes were probably my favourite.… (mer)
 
Flaggad
Rob3rt | 1 annan recension | Mar 3, 2016 |
In Harrison's first major work on ancient Greek religion (Prolegomena), she innovated by applying archaeological data to support her conviction that Homer and the great tragedians gave only a very partial view of the religious life that they purported to reference. She explored a chthonian, matrifocal, and magical stratum prior to, shadowing, and outlasting the Olympian cults. In the later Themis, she is concerned more precisely with questions of genealogy and development. She has embraced Emile Durkheim's ideas about the primacy of the social, to good effect. She traces several developmental arcs by which the reified forms of magical power (mana in the anthropological argot of her day) become individualized from ambient sanctities of natural forces and generic daimons of generative power into the persons of heroes and "high" Olympian gods. Her contempt for the latter is unconcealed; she finds them sterile, too removed from the vital numen which originates in communal feeling and pre-individual social impulses.

There is some curious irony in her judgment that the "first and foremost among the services Olympianism rendered to Greece" was to "purge ... [the] exclusively phallic" components from religion, claiming that such features are "an obvious source of danger and disease" in civilized settings where human culture centers on human activity rather than the rhythms of non-human nature. (460) This passage late in the book is the one in which she most clearly calls out the phallic elements that have been implicit in the daimon concept throughout her account of it. Hers is not a simply phallic theory of religious origins, however. With the reverence for the generative powers in her daimon concept, she mixes a gradually maturing sense of the cosmos, in a sequence that invariably progresses from plants and soil, to storms and weather, to the moon, and then to the sun. (390) (Qabalists will note a symbolic progression up the middle pillar, from Malkuth, through Yesod, to Tiphareth.)

The framing conceit of Themis is that it is simply an effort to explicate a ritual hymn in honor of the birth of Zeus. In the course of the book, however, the hymn is often far over the horizon, while the author expounds one or another feature of ancient Greek religion. At the book's end, she returns to the hymn, which itself ends with the imperative to "leap ... for goodly Themis." According to Harrison, Themis is a representation of human culture, "collective conscience, social sanction," and thus "the substratum of each and every god." (485)

The volume includes contributions from two of Harrison's peers among the Cambridge Ritualists, an early 20th century circle of classical scholars of whom Harrison--on the evidence of this volume at least--is certainly the most engaging. Gilbert Murray provides a very interesting analysis of the ritual infrastructure of Greek tragedy, illustrated a little too exhaustively with examples that presume the reader's familiarity with the works being related to the pattern. F.M. Cornford's chapter on the ritual genealogy of the ancient Olympic games depends on the reader to appreciate a rather generous amount of untranslated Greek. This is a tendency that Harrison herself tends to keep to her footnotes, although she does feel the need to finish the entire book with an untranslated Greek sentence. It should be remarked that this book is clearly the product of a scholarly culture, barely even addressed to the intelligent layman, despite the general interest of its topic. Harrison freely quotes Nietzsche in German and Durkheim in French, without feeling any obligation to assist the reader. (I could manage the former but not the latter.)

Harrison is refreshingly honest about her own religious perspective, in a field where a pretense of clinical detachment was par for the course. "[P]rofoundly as I also feel the value of the religious impulse, so keenly do I feel the danger and almost necessary disaster of each and every creed and dogma," she writes in her introduction. "As for religious ritual, we may by degrees find forms that are free from intellectual error." (xxiii) I certainly concur on both counts. As far as her theories of religious evolution are concerned, she sees magic as a necessary prerequisite for religion (215-216), and theology as a non-essential "phase" of religious articulation. (488) The first was a sentiment common to those who, like Harrison, saw themselves in sympathy to the work of J.G. Frazer. But the second was an uncommonly insightful and provocative position for a book published in 1912.
… (mer)
2 rösta
Flaggad
paradoxosalpha | 1 annan recension | Jan 15, 2010 |

Priser

Du skulle kanske också gilla

Associerade författare

Ray Garnett Illustrator

Statistik

Verk
24
Även av
2
Medlemmar
647
Popularitet
#39,006
Betyg
3.9
Recensioner
8
ISBN
78
Språk
2
Favoritmärkt
2

Tabeller & diagram