John Parker (1) (1938–)

As I knew nothing about the Foreign Legion other than what I've picked up through movies and general references in the media, I thought this book might provide an interesting insight into what life is like as a Legionnaire. What I found instead was not so much a description of life in the Foreign Legion as a survey of its history and battles. That does not mean the book was not interesting; I learned a great deal. But I wish the book gave a deeper view into daily life in the Legion. If you want a general history of the Foreign Legion, this is the book for you. If you want to see what life would be like if you joined the Foreign Legion, this gives you only a glimpse (probably enough to decide whether life in the Legion is for you, but not many details).… (mer)

I initially had high hopes for this book, but was sorely disappointed. The writing is flat and the description of most events is superficial. I did enjoy the chapters which contained excerpts of letters from the two Stewart brothers who served as officers in WW I. The portion concerning the North African campaigns were good.
Overall, you would be better off going to wikipedia to get detailed information on the various battles. I did this to get information on the battle of Magersfontein of the Boers Wars. Wiki was much more informative.… (mer)

Interesante lectura sobre la historia del submarino. La primera parte, de los inicios a la Gran Guerra, está francamente bien resuelta. Buenos datos, conciso. Lamentablemente la segunda parte es algo más acelerada, dando la sensación de que es un cajón de sastre. Resulta sorprendente que la parte dedicada a los submarinos alemanes -especialmente el Tipo VII- sea tan corta, cuando es la más conocida.

Por suerte, y eso es el punto a favor del libro, el autor profundiza bastante en la historia de los sumergibles británicos y sus hazañas; francamente interesantes tanto en la Primera Guerra Mundial -las acciones contra Turquía- como en la Segunda Guerra Mundial, la clase X, por citar un ejemplo, y las incursiones contra el Tirpitz.

Las ilustraciones como e siempre en esta editorial muy buenas.… (mer)