Katie Slivensky
Författare till The Countdown Conspiracy
Verk av Katie Slivensky
Taggad
Allmänna fakta
- Kön
- female
- Nationalitet
- USA
- Bostadsorter
- Michigan, USA
Massachusetts, USA
Medlemmar
Recensioner
Priser
Statistik
- Verk
- 3
- Medlemmar
- 78
- Popularitet
- #229,022
- Betyg
- 3.7
- Recensioner
- 3
- ISBN
- 8
The idea is solid. There is some inclusivity (Miranda has her numbers and order thing). Not sure about other characters, did not get that far. Supposedly it has diversity, what with kids from different countries. Again - not sure how well it's tackled because did not get far.
"Merit for the win" is a good approach in the world full of stories about Very Special Snowflakes. Though one could argue how there are whooping SIX Snowflakes in this story, of which Miranda happens to be one. So the jury is out on this particular bit.
It's written in first person, which I find problematic more often than not. It just raises flags from the get-go. *shrug* Generally it would not be much of a problem. BUT, a big fat BUT. The writing sounds NOTHING like a 13-year-old, nevermind how smart they are. If read without any prior information, this could be pegged as YA. It just doesn't have the feel of an MG book.
The writing is somewhat clunky and bogged down by unnecessary descriptions and weird phrasing. It was also quite tedious, and no kid would keep reading when nothing seems to happen. Because nothing much happened by the time I abandoned all hope and quit. And that's with me persisting. Kids would drop it sooner IMO.
On paper it sound like a good read for kids with interest in science, adventure and space. Yet here we are. The reality is quite different.
FINAL VERDICT : CANNOT RECOMMEND… (mer)