Edward Steers, Jr.
Författare till Blood on the Moon: The Assassination of Abraham Lincoln
Om författaren
Edward Steers Jr., a recognized authority on the Lincoln assassination, is the author of several books, including Getting Right with Lincoln: Correcting Misconceptions about Our Greatest President, Blood on the Moon: The Assassination of Abraham Lincoln, and Lincoln Legends: Myths, Hoaxes, and visa mer Contabulations Associated with Our Greatest President. visa färre
Foto taget av: Ed Steers
Verk av Edward Steers, Jr.
Lincoln Legends: Myths, Hoaxes, and Confabulations Associated with Our Greatest President (2007) 130 exemplar
The Trial: The Assassination of President Lincoln and the Trial of the Conspirators (2003) 34 exemplar
The Lincoln Assassination Conspirators: Their Confinement and Execution, as Recorded in the Letterbook of John… (2009) 33 exemplar
Getting Right with Lincoln: Correcting Misconceptions about Our Greatest President (2021) 5 exemplar
Taggad
Allmänna fakta
Medlemmar
Recensioner
Du skulle kanske också gilla
Associerade författare
Statistik
- Verk
- 21
- Medlemmar
- 691
- Popularitet
- #36,611
- Betyg
- 4.0
- Recensioner
- 9
- ISBN
- 45
Ch. 1: A decent recapitulation of the Mark Hoffman case, with a focus on the "Oath of a Freeman," not his Mormon forgeries. Pretty good, though.
Ch. 2: The chapter focuses on some supposed transcripts of a conversation between Churchill and FDR that did not happen: they were a hoax. What is left undone is a thorough rebuttal of the conspiracy theory based on the facts that are facts. This is better done elsewhere.
Ch. 3: A nice retelling of the Hitler Diaries hoax.
Ch. 4: A skeptical account of the Shroud of Turin, with some evidence I haven't heard before. A Dr. McCrone says the "blood" isn't blood? I've always read that it is blood? The Catholic Church traced down the forger in the 1300s? Here the skeptic takes a Church document rather unskeptically. Most Shroud researchers believe that we have references to the shroud going back before it pops up in France. It is good to see an account of a Shroud skeptic, since most Shroud books are pro it being an authentic relic. Steers relies quite heavily on his foreword writer Nickell's work here.
Ch. 5: The Piltdown Man hoax is told here, with the blame falling squarely on Dawson, who probably forged other artifacts. Fine. But Steers seems to believe that the hoax was accepted for nationalistic reasons: Brits were racist jingos who wanted an "ancestor" of their own back in the human family tree. Steers doesn't seem to consider that scientists might have wanted a missing link because they wanted to prove Darwinistic evolution. Scientists (it is repeated again and again that Dawson was an amateur) can't have sinister motives, can they?
Ch. 6: Steers focuses on the missing pages from the John Wilkes Booth diary. This is Steers's area of expertise (he is a scholar of the Lincoln assassination) and he demolishes several conspiracy theories about Stanton and Booth, etc. He makes a good stab at showing that the pages were probably already torn from the diary when taken off Booth, not after it got to Stanton. (Though, to be fair, we know some pages were torn out for notes. But could some have been torn out after the diary got to Stanton? Sure. We have no way of proving that one way or the other.)
All-in-all, a good book. But it has the underlying aura trying to show that BELIEF is what contaminates right thinking. Perhaps I am trying too hard to dislike an aspect of this book, but something about it seemed condescending and I can't quite put a finger on it.
Images, notes, suggested readings.… (mer)