Författarbild

John Williams (5) (1908–1998)

Författare till Frankrikes fall

För andra författare vid namn John Williams, se särskiljningssidan.

7 verk 169 medlemmar 3 recensioner

Verk av John Williams

Taggad

Allmänna fakta

Namn enligt folkbokföringen
Williams, John Herbert
Födelsedag
1908-03-13
Avled
1998
Kön
male
Nationalitet
UK
Yrken
historian
Organisationer
Royal Artillery (UK) (WWII)

Medlemmar

Recensioner

Book 21: [The Ides of May: the Defeat of France, May-June, 1940] by John Williams



This is an excellent history, well written and extremely well researched. That it is extremely frustrating to read says nothing about the author and everything about the subject matter. For this book is about the utter failure of the French nation and French army to prepare for war against Germany in the 1930s/1940s, and the failures and miscalculations that allowed the German armed forces to roll over the French in only two month's time.

Williams' research, in particular his extensive use of the diaries of the French leaders, allowed him to recreate conversations and take the reader inside conferences as the situation becomes more desperate and the participants more frantic.

A particularly fascinating section is Williams' description of the first two days of the German occupation of Paris, following the French leaders' agonizing yet clearly sound decision not to defend the city.

As Williams put it succinctly in his foreword:

"This is the history of the defeat of the French Army in the battles of May and June 1940. It is a story of unrelieved catastrophe in which the whole fabric of France was involved . . . When the cease fire took effect on June 25, the French Army had been in action for forty-six days--but it was already beaten by the middle of May. . . . {I}t was clear that the primary blame for what was, after all, a military defeat lay squarely with the French General Staff and High Command. The generals and the operations planners went to war in 1939 still thinking largely in terms of 1914-1918. Staking their faith on the old doctrine of the defensive, they continued to see warfare as static. They rejected the new theories of mobile war based on the concentrated use of tanks and aircraft and, instead, perpetuated the trench mentality of World War I. . . . Thus when the massed German panzers and dive bombers struck westward on May 12, the French were at the mercy of a fast-moving armored onslaught that proved irresistible. . . . The fall of France in June 1940 was a tragedy of lost military opportunities: lost during the eight months' lull in the West when the French army chiefs might still have revised their strategic and operational planning to counter the coming mechanized attack; and earlier, during the whole two decades from 1919 when they persistently refused to read the signs and continued to envisage and prepare for a type of war that was obsolete.

The book is, basically, a 375-page explication of this premise. It's therefore a difficult reading experience a lot of the time, but it is a fascinating one nevertheless.

I would have liked to read some "falling action," as the book stops immediately upon the signing of the armistice between France and Germany. Some information about the actions of Vichy France and the French armed forces that remained in the French colonial territories at that time, among other topics, would have been helpful to put the events of the book in better context.
… (mer)
 
Flaggad
rocketjk | 1 annan recension | Aug 26, 2014 |
Unlike the book by Arthur Marder that I found quite interesting, this work has no memories for me at all. If you can't find another book on the topic, this one exists.
 
Flaggad
DinadansFriend | Aug 15, 2014 |
991 The Ides of May: The Defeat of France May-June 1940, by John Williams (read 5 Jan 1969) An absorbing account of the fall of France in 1940. While the book is somewhat superficial, it does present in all its awful detail the story of France's fall--I should not say "all." German sources are little used. And while the sketch covering the period from 1870 to 1939 is swiftly and competently done, there is no epilogue: sketching the events after June 1940. I think the future course of Gamelin, Weygand, Reynaud, etc., might well have been referred to. So much to read; such interesting and absorbing things; this book is not momentous but the events it details are stupendously so.… (mer)
½
 
Flaggad
Schmerguls | 1 annan recension | Jul 16, 2009 |

Du skulle kanske också gilla

Associerade författare

Dan Coates Arranger
Patrick Doyle Composer
Boston Pops Orchestra Performers, Orchestra
Erich Kunzel Conductor
George Johnston Contributor
David Rome Contributor
Olaf Ruhen Contributor
Steve Kaldor Contributor
Robyn Tracey Contributor
Martin Loran Contributor
Frank Roberts Contributor
T.F. Kline Contributor
Lee Harding Contributor
Douglas Stewart Contributor
Michael Wilding Contributor
Tod Edmondson Arranger
Ethan Neuburg Arranger
Tony Esposito Arranger
The Boston Pops Orchestra
Antonio Lauro Composer
Boston Pops Orchestra
George Gascoigne Contributor
Thomas Nashe Contributor
Sir Thomas Wyatt Contributor
John Skelton Contributor
Sir Philip Sidney Contributor
Thomas Campion Contributor
Thomas Lodge Contributor
George Turberville Contributor
Ben Jonson Contributor
Edmund Spenser Contributor
Robert Greene Contributor
Thomas Vaux Contributor
Robert Peele Contributor
John Donne Contributor
Samuel Daniel Contributor
Fulke Greville Contributor
Walter Ralegh Contributor
Sir Edward Dyer Contributor
Thomas More Contributor
Michael Drayton Contributor
Henry Howard Contributor
Barnabe Googe Contributor
Teena Chinn Arranger
Harold Prince Producer
Topol Performer
Michele Marsh Performer
Norma Crane Performer
Isaac Stern Performer
Yo-Yo Ma Artist, Performer
Margot Kidder Contributor
Niall Griffiths Contributor
Cole Porter Songwriter
Darlene Love Performer
Mel Tormé Performer
Jackie Harland Illustrator
Itzak Perlman Performer
Edzard Krol Translator
Ilkka Rekiaro Translator
John McGahern Afterword, Introduction
Marie Rodell Contributor
Bernhard Robben Translator
George Giusti Cover designer
Michelle Latiolais Introduction
Richard Erdoes Cover artist
Bruno Oddera Translator
Daniel Mendelsohn Introduction
Robert Pinsky Introduction
Zubin Mehta Conductor
Bruce Wolfe Cover artist
Denny Tillman Photographer

Statistik

Verk
7
Medlemmar
169
Popularitet
#126,057
Betyg
½ 3.3
Recensioner
3
ISBN
845
Språk
30

Tabeller & diagram