| Titlar | Ordning |
| The Patchwork Quilt av Valerie Flournoy | New Writer Award, 1986 |
| Jamaica's Find av Juanita Havill | New Writer Award, 1987 |
| Anna's Special Present (Picture Puffins) av Yoriko Tsutsui | New Writer Award, 1989 |
| Tell Me A Story, Mama av Angela Johnson | New Writer Award, 1991 |
| Tar Beach av Faith Ringgold | New Writer Award, 1993 |
| Taxi! Taxi! av Cari Best | New Writer Award, 1995 |
| Calling the Doves/El canto de las palomas av Juan Felipe Herrera | New Writer Award, 1997 |
| Elizabeti's Doll av Stephanie Stuve-Bodeen | New Writer Award, 1999 |
| Dear Juno (Picture Puffins) av Soyung Pak | New Writer Award, 2000 |
| Henry Hikes to Fitchburg av D. B. Johnson | New Writer Award, 2001 |
| Uptown av Bryan Collier | New Illustrator Award, 2001 |
| Freedom Summer av Deborah Wiles | New Writer Award, 2002; New Illustrator Award, 2002 |
| Ruby's Wish av Shirin Yim Bridges | New Writer Award, 2003; New Illustrator Award, 2003 |
| Yesterday I Had the Blues av Jeron Ashford Frame | New Writer Award, 2004 |
| My Name is Yoon av Helen Recorvits | New Illustrator Award, 2004 |
| Going North av Janice N. Harrington | New Writer Award, 2005 |
| The Night Eater av Ana Juan | New Illustrator Award, 2005 |
| My Best Friend av Mary Ann Rodman | New Writer Award, 2006 |
| Silly Chicken av Rukhsana Khan | New Illustrator Award, 2006 |
| For You Are a Kenyan Child av Kelly Cunnane | New Writer Award, 2007 |
| Mystery Bottle av Kristen Balouch | New Illustrator Award, 2007 |
| Leaves av David Ezra Stein | New Writer Award, 2008 |
| The Apple Pie That Papa Baked av Lauren Thompson | New Illustrator Award, 2008 |
| Hermans sommar av Stian Hole | New Writer Award, 2009 |
| Bird av Zetta Elliott | New Illustrator Award, 2009 |
| Most Loved in All the World av Tonya C. Hegamin | New Writer Award, 2010 |
| Only a Witch Can Fly av Alison McGhee | New Illustrator Award, 2010 |
| I Know Here av Laurel Croza | New Writer Award, 2011 |
| Bunny Days av Tao Nyeu | New Illustrator Award, 2011 |
| Tia Isa Wants a Car av Meg Medina | New Writer Award, 2012 |
| Cinnamon Baby av Nicola Winstanley | New Writer Honor, 2012 |
| Same, Same But Different av Jenny Sue Kostecki-Shaw | New Illustrator Award, 2012; New Writer Honor 2012 |
| Lola's Fandango av Anna Witte | New Illustrator Honor, 2012 |
| Not Inside This House! av Kevin Lewis | New Illustrator Honor, 2012 |
| And Then It's Spring av Julie Fogliano | New Writer Award, 2013 |
| It Jes' Happened: When Bill Traylor Started to Draw av Don Tate | New Writer Honor, 2013 |
| My Heart Will Not Sit Down av Mara Rockliff | New Writer Honor, 2013 |
| The Stamp Collector av Jennifer Lanthier | New Writer Honor, 2013 |
| Mom, It's My First Day of Kindergarten! av Hyewon Yum | New Illustrator Award, 2013 |
| Ganesha's Sweet Tooth av Sanjay Patel | New Illustrator Honor, 2013 |
| Lester's dreadful sweaters av K. G. Campbell | New Illustrator Honor, 2013 |
| Tea Party Rules av Ame Dyckman | New Writer Award, 2014; New Illustrator Honor, 2014 |
| I Love You, Nose! I Love You, Toes! av Linda Davick | New Writer Honor, 2014 |
| Sophie's Squash av Pat Zietlow Miller | New Writer Honor, 2014 |
| Rain! av Linda Ashman | New Illustrator Award, 2014 |
| My Grandpa av Marta Altes | New Illustrator Honor, 2014 |
| Take Me Out to the Yakyu av Aaron Meshon | New Illustrator Honor, 2014 |
| Hana Hashimoto, Sixth Violin av Chieri Uegaki | New Writer Award, 2015 |
| A Boy and a Jaguar av Alan Rabinowitz | New Writer Honor, 2015 |
| Edda: A Little Valkyrie's First Day of School av Adam Auerbach | New Writer Honor, 2015 |
| Firebird av Misty Copeland | New Writer Honor, 2015 |
| Schh! Vi har en plan av Chris Haughton | New Illustrator Award, 2015 |
| Grandfather Gandhi av Arun Gandhi | New Illustrator Honor, 2015 |
| Little Elliot, Big City av Mike Curato | New Illustrator Honor, 2015 |
| Poet: The Remarkable Story of George Moses Horton av Don Tate | New Writer Award, 2016 |
| Sonya's Chickens av Phoebe Wahl | New Illustrator Award, 2016 |
