Klicka på en bild för att gå till Google Book Search.
Laddar... Socrates: A Man for Our Times (2011)av Paul Johnson
Ingen/inga Laddar...
Gå med i LibraryThing för att få reda på om du skulle tycka om den här boken. Det finns inga diskussioner på LibraryThing om den här boken. Almost a novel, albeit with a lot of historical background. This is because so little is known of the real Socrates, I guess. ( ) This is a necessarily short book. We know little about Socrates's life and all of it indirectly. He lived, after all, twenty-five hundred years ago. I would like to give it a higher rating, and please note that the rating I gave it is purely a reflection of the biographer, not its subject, whom I admire. Mostly I was annoyed by Johnson's lack of objectivity. He's primarily a journalist not a historian, and it shows---particularly after having read Oleg Khlekniuk's careful biography of Stalin. Johnson's book is rife with opinion presented as fact. An example: ``[Athens] was the cultural capital of the civilized world.'' So much for objectivity, to say nothing it being offensive to any of a number of contemporaneous civilizations (China's Zhou dynasty was 500 years old at the time of Socrates). Hell, at least acknowledge this is a matter of opinion not fact, you arrogant ass. A judgmental gem: Plato's ideas about the soul are referred to as ``absurd.'' Oh, pray tell us, Mr. Johnson, what is the true nature of the soul and how did you come by this information? Smug bastard. As an account of Socrates's life, it seems fine. The biographer's first task is to make the biographee sympathetic. Hard with some subjects, but easy enough with Socrates. Johnson manages this, but too much. He's more a cheerleader than a proper biographer. It's technically well-written, but the writing is academically shitty. I had only read Plato’s dialogues, and so only knew Socrates from Plato. Great to get a more complete picture of the man, and not just the character Plato created. As an example, I had no idea that Socrates had lived through Periclean Athens, and through its downfall and domination by Sparta after the Peloponnesian War. I had always believed his trial and execution were conducted during Athens’ golden age, and couldn’t understand why it happened in such an otherwise enlightened city. But, in fact, his trial was after the reign of the 30 Tyrants, who had effectively ended Athenian Democracy by the time charges were brought against Socrates. A well summarized view and look at the life of Socrates. The first few chapters details Athens and Greek society as a whole. It also goes heavily into the Sophists, Plato, democracy, and a lot on Pericles and how his governing of Athens affected Socrates. It also goes into Euripedes and Aristophanes a lot and how they affected his life (especially Aristophanes' Clouds play). Sadly, due to nothing being written by Socrates we have to take a lot from Xenophon, Plato, and others. And Plato tended to use Socrates name as a vehicle for his own philosophies. The author does a fair bit of 'guess-work' which at times hinders the book I think. He'll say things like "Socrates did this, and I believe this is why" or other such things. And granted we don't know the blanks, I'm not a big fan of hearsay in a non-fiction biographical piece of work. The author does a fair job of highlighting Socrates' strengths and comparing them to some more modern aspects and people and showing how his life is relevant to our times. inga recensioner | lägg till en recension
Socrates is often called the father of philosophy. Yet he left no writings, so what we know of his life and ideas comes from the works of his contemporaries. Socrates taught--and strove to embody--that how each of us chooses to live and die has great meaning. By constantly examining one's life and actions, a philosophy of ethics is born. As Plutarch observed, "He was the first person to demonstrate that life is open to philosophy at all times, in every part, among all kinds of people, and in every experience and activity." In this biography, historian Paul Johnson situates Socrates in the life of fifth-century B.C. Athens, and his wide range of acquaintances, from the local grocer to the leading politicians, dramatists, and scholars. By studying his life and times, we benefit from his philosophy, for as Cicero said, "Socrates was the first to call Philosophy down from the skies ... and introduce her into people's homes, and force her to investigate ordinary life, ethics, good and evil."--From publisher description. Inga biblioteksbeskrivningar kunde hittas. |
Pågående diskussionerIngen/ingaPopulära omslag
Google Books — Laddar... GenrerMelvil Decimal System (DDC)183.2Philosophy and Psychology Ancient, medieval and eastern philosophy Sophistic and Socratic SocratesKlassifikation enligt LCBetygMedelbetyg:
Är det här du?Penguin AustraliaEn utgåva av denna bok gavs ut av Penguin Australia. Recorded BooksEn utgåva av denna bok gavs ut av Recorded Books. |