Grudem's title may be a bit inflammatory, but his argument is thorough and convincing. He illustrates through numerous example how the hermeneutical compromises necessary to adopt an egalitarian position undermine ones ability to hold to biblical inerrancy. To those who point to the numerous scholars who make such compromises while holding to a high view of Scripture, he illustrates the inconsistency necessary to hold to both. His argument is clear and compelling. He shows why this issue is indeed a litmus issue in the contemporary evangelical world. ( )